Expert review

Expert review

Expert review involves an identified expert providing a review of draft documents at specified stages of a process and/or planned processes. For an evaluation, these might include: evaluation brief; Terms of Reference; evaluation design or plan; evaluation report; M&E framework.

Example(s)

Department for International Development Help Desk:

The UK Department for International Development (DfID) has contracted a consulting firm, and a network of advisors, to provide time-sensitive review of evaluation-related products. Specifically, in the form of undertaking quality assurance of terms of reference, inception reports (which include an evaluation plan) and evaluation reports, using standardised templates.

Advice

Advice for USING this option

Organisations may wish to consider developing an internal expert review process for evaluation products.
When developing an expert review process, ensure there is clear guidance on what standards are expected and communicate these well to those creating the documents for review and reviewers. Templates, examples, and guidance documents can assist with this.

This page is a Stub (a minimal version of a page). You can help expand it. Click on Contribute Content or Contact Us to suggest additional resources, share your experience using the method, or volunteer to expand description.

Source

Peersman, G. and Rogers, P. (2017). Pathways to advance professionalisation within the context of the Australasian Evaluation Society. Melbourne: ANZSOG/BetterEvaluation. Retrieved from: https://www.betterevaluation.org/en/resources/pathways-advance-professio...