Expert Review for meta-evaluation

Synonyms: 
Peer/Expert Reviews

An expert review involves experts reviewing the evaluation, drawing in part on their expertise and experience of the particular type of program or project.

"There may be people who hold special knowledge about your collaborative or the issue it has formed to address. Inviting these "experts" to review the performance of your collaborative can provide useful answers to many evaluation questions. Such experts could be key stakeholders of the collaborative, people involved in similar collaborative initiatives in another community, or educators from a local school or university.

Adequate preparation for an expert review is paramount. As you plan for an expert review, consider the following:

  • WHO is best qualified to evaluate the collaborative? Who will be seen as credible? How many will be included?
  • WHEN will the "experts" review the collaborative's work? How long will the review take? What date are most appropriate?
  • WHAT will the "experts" be expected to look at? What questions might they answer?" (Taylor-Powell, Rossing, et al., 1998)

Example

Do you have an example of where this option has been used? Click on Contribute Content or Contact Us to share your example of this option.

Advice

Do you have any advice for CHOOSING or USING this option? Click on Contribute Content or Contact Us to share your experience choosing or using this option.

Resources

Overview

  • Assessing the impact of research on policy: In this overview the authors discuss a variety of evaluation options and show that using both internal and external evaluators might enrich the assessment through bringing different perspectives into the evaluation.

Sources

Taylor-Powell, E., B. Rossing, et al. (1998). Evaluating Collaboratives: Reaching the potential. Program Development and Evaluation. Madison, Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin-Extension: 190. http://learningstore.uwex.edu/pdf/G3658-8.PDF

Fish Viewing Photo by Tan Heok Hui via  N. Sivasothi, Raffles Museum of Biodiversity Research, Department of Biological Sciences, National University of Singapore.

This page is a stub (a minimal version of a page). You can help expand it.  Click on Contribute Content or Contact Us to suggest additional resources, share your experience using the option, or volunteer to expand the description.

Updated: 6th March 2014 - 11:16am
A special thanks to this page's contributors
Author
Research Assistant, RMIT University.
Melbourne.
Reviewer
Director of BetterEvaluation/ Professor of Public Sector Evaluation, Australia and New Zealand School of Government.
Melbourne.

Comments

There are currently no comments. Be the first to comment on this page!

Add new comment

Login Login and comment as BetterEvaluation member or simply fill out the fields below.